DeviantArt: A Deep Dive into the Online Art Community

Posted on: Posted on

DeviantArt: A Deep Dive into the Online Art Community

DeviantArt is a massive online art community and website. Here’s a comprehensive overview, covering its history, features, pros & cons, recent changes, and its place in the art world:

What is DeviantArt?

At its core, DeviantArt is a platform for artists to showcase their work, connect with other artists, and receive feedback. It supports a huge range of artistic mediums, including:

  • Traditional Art: Painting, drawing, sculpture, crafts
  • Digital Art: Digital painting, illustration, photo manipulation, 3D art, vector art
  • Photography: Landscape, portrait, macro, abstract, etc.
  • Writing: Poetry, prose, fanfiction
  • Music: Original compositions, remixes
  • Cosplay: Costume creation and performance
  • Animation: Short films, GIFs
  • And more! (including resources like brushes, textures, and tutorials)

History

  • Founded: August 2000 by Angelo Sotira. Initially, it was a place for artists to share and discuss digital art, particularly DeviantArt-created artwork.
  • Early Growth: Quickly gained popularity as a haven for artists, especially those interested in anime, manga, and fan art.
  • Expansion: Expanded to include all forms of art and became a central hub for the online art community.
  • Ownership Changes: In 2017, DeviantArt was acquired by Eclipse Holdings, a company owned by Matthew Stephens. This led to significant changes (more on that later).
  • Widespread Adoption: For many years, it was the dominant online art platform. While competition has increased, it remains a significant player.

Key Features

  • Galleries: Artists organize their work into galleries.
  • Watch: Users can “watch” artists to follow their new submissions.
  • Faves (Favorites): Users can “fave” artwork they like, acting as a bookmark and showing appreciation.
  • Comments: A core feature for providing feedback and engaging in discussion.
  • Groups: Communities focused on specific themes, styles, or fandoms. A great way to find like-minded artists and get targeted feedback.
  • Forums: Discussion boards covering a wide range of topics.
  • Journals: Blog-like posts where artists can share updates, thoughts, and process work.
  • Commissions: Artists can offer commissions (custom artwork for a fee).
  • Prints: DeviantArt offers print-on-demand services, allowing artists to sell physical prints of their work.
  • Core Membership: A paid subscription offering benefits like ad-free browsing, increased storage, and access to exclusive features.
  • AI Art Generation: DeviantArt has integrated AI art generation tools (DreamStudio) which has been a controversial topic (see “Controversies” below).
  • Promoted Deviations: Artists can pay to promote their work to a wider audience.

Pros of DeviantArt

  • Large Community: Massive user base means a lot of potential exposure and feedback.
  • Diverse Art Styles: You’ll find art in virtually every style imaginable.
  • Free to Use (Basic Account): You can create an account and share your art for free.
  • Networking Opportunities: Connect with other artists, find collaborators, and build relationships.
  • Learning Resources: Tutorials, critiques, and discussions can help you improve your skills.
  • Print Sales: Easy way to sell prints of your work.
  • Commission Opportunities: A platform to find clients for custom artwork.
  • Long-Standing Platform: A well-established community with a rich history.

Cons of DeviantArt

  • Outdated Interface (Historically): The interface was often criticized for being clunky and difficult to navigate. The “Eclipse” redesign (see below) attempted to address this, but remains divisive.
  • Algorithm Issues: The algorithm can be unpredictable, making it difficult to get your work seen.
  • Spam & Low-Quality Content: Like any large platform, DeviantArt has its share of spam and low-effort submissions.
  • Art Theft: Art theft is a concern, although DeviantArt has tools to report and address it.
  • Controversial AI Integration: The integration of AI art generation has been highly controversial (see below).
  • Core Membership Push: Some users feel pressured to purchase Core Membership to gain visibility.
  • Moderation Concerns: Some users have raised concerns about the effectiveness of moderation.

The “Eclipse” Redesign (and its aftermath)

In 2020, DeviantArt rolled out a major redesign called “Eclipse.” This was a very controversial move.

  • Goals: The redesign aimed to modernize the interface, improve mobile responsiveness, and enhance the user experience.
  • Criticism: Many users strongly disliked the new interface, finding it cluttered, confusing, and less intuitive than the previous design. Common complaints included:
    • Difficult navigation
    • Poor organization of galleries
    • Loss of customization options
    • Performance issues
  • Forced Adoption: DeviantArt eventually forced all users to use the Eclipse interface, leading to a significant exodus of artists to other platforms.
  • Ongoing Updates: DeviantArt continues to make updates to the interface, but it remains a point of contention for many long-time users.

DeviantArt and AI Art: A Major Controversy

DeviantArt has become a central battleground in the debate surrounding AI-generated art.

  • DreamStudio Integration: DeviantArt partnered with Stability AI to integrate DreamStudio, an AI art generator, directly into the platform.
  • Data Scraping Concerns: A major point of contention is that Stability AI trained its AI model (Stable Diffusion) on a massive dataset of images scraped from the internet, including artwork from DeviantArt, often without the artists’ consent.
  • Copyright Issues: Artists are concerned about copyright infringement and the potential for AI to replicate their styles without permission.
  • “Protect” Feature: DeviantArt introduced a “Protect” feature allowing artists to opt-out their artwork from being used in AI training datasets. However, its effectiveness has been questioned.
  • Ongoing Debate: The debate over AI art on DeviantArt is ongoing, with artists, developers, and legal experts weighing in on the ethical and legal implications. It’s a complex issue with no easy answers.

Alternatives to DeviantArt

  • ArtStation: Popular among professional artists, particularly in the game and film industries. Focuses on high-quality portfolio presentation.
  • Pixiv: A Japanese art community, particularly strong in anime and manga.
  • Instagram: A widely used social media platform for sharing art.
  • Twitter (X): Good for quick updates and engaging with a wider audience.
  • Tumblr: A microblogging platform with a strong art community.
  • Newgrounds: A long-standing platform for independent artists, animators, and game developers.
  • Carrd/Personal Website: Creating your own website gives you complete control over your presentation and branding.

Where to find more information

In conclusion

DeviantArt remains a significant force in the online art world, despite its controversies and competition. It’s a complex platform with a rich history, a large community, and a lot to offer artists. However, it’s important to be aware of its drawbacks and consider whether it’s the right platform for your needs. The ongoing debate surrounding AI art will undoubtedly continue to shape DeviantArt’s future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *